Book-Buying = Addiction. Good marketing slogan? Not so much
June 3rd, 2009 by Vanessa
We didn’t go to the Booksellers Association conference earlier this week. We were planning to as it was supposed to be being held in Gateshead at a rather swanky new conference centre. But there were complaints about the distance from London and so the venue was changed to Cambridge. That’s over 5 hours on a train with two changes and then another 20 miles by coach (or £20 cab if you missed the coaches) to the conference centre. Frankly, although the Independent Booksellers’ Forum organised in Edinburgh in March was good fun and really useful we couldn’t really spare the time to trek down there. Holding it outside London was a good idea in some respects but to be honest, we’d have gone if it had been held in London as we could have seen friends as well and the train journey is 4 hours of peace each way to read and work.
Anyway, having established why we weren’t there, it’s been interesting over the last day or two to catch up on what did happen. Sadly, Yeadon’s didn’t win the Independent Bookshop of the Year Nibbie for Scotland although our near-neighbours Canongate did win a gong to add to the awards they’ve garnered recently having had their best year ever.
But something did leap out at me this morning. Apparently, the book trade is going to have a new marketing slogan; an over-arching concept reaching across all aspects of the booktrade which will promote book-buying to the public. So far, so good. After all, the milk ads have been successful in using athletes, actresses, slebs et al to promote the positive aspects of drinking milk without promoting one supplier over another.
So what is this concept, arrived at after “marketing directors were consulted, then a cross-industry creative workshop convened from which four key conceptual threads were teased: books are great; books are good for you; books are good value; and word plays. The selection criteria were cut-through, flexibility, longevity, re-appraisal; and PR platform potential”?
“Bookaholism” – that’s what they came up with. Yes people, we’re going to liken a love of books to an addiction to alcohol. That’s classy. And it gets worse. Apparently ”among the slogans likely to be seen in the campaign – which, having been green-lit, will be prioritised and rolled out before Christmas – are “Consume no less than one a month”, “Class A reading material”, “This book is seriously addictive”, “Once you’ve started it’s hard to stop” [sorry, but that was Pringles - are we now likening our industry to crisp-selling?], and “Books are mind expanding” – I can’t see those working in our children’s bookshop or among the Morningside matrons who make up a large part of our customer base: “Yes madam, do try the new Eoin Colfer, I believe it’s very similar to crack cocaine”… Maybe not.
Damien Horner, who seems to have installed himself at the Booksellers Association as the resident ‘marketing guru’, described it as “an edgy campaign that is clever, fun, flexible, memorable and a PR catapult”. ‘PR catapult’ has won a special prize in our office for the most ridiculous phrase we’ve heard so far this year. Along with “top-of-mind awareness” which will apparently be an added bonus of this campaign. Sheesh.
It gets better, not only are we having this foisted on us - although I think we might be resisting vigorously – but we’re being patronised. The BA and the Publishers Association (largely made up of representatives from the bigger publishers and the people who commissioned that research into age-ranging that was so reviled and discredited last year) are going to co-fund this scheme “by a few for the benefit of the many”. Gosh thanks guys.
Although my command of cliches can’t compete with this scheme, it feels only right to end with one. Things can only get better.
Good…grief.
The only sane response to this is to keep doing what you and other independents do. Individual enterprise, personal recommendation, talking to your customers, and a whole lot of passion and determination. Plus judicious use of the Oxford comma.
Actually they could have done what Waterst… Wa*choke*t… that chain did and simply consulted a copy of the Oxford Dictionary of Quotations for bunch of punchy, memorable quotes to use on their carrier bags. Why not go to the source?
I was rather fond of the American Booksellers Association ‘Eat. Sleep. Read.’ campaign.
http://www.bookweb.org/files/open/pdf/indiebound/IndieBoundFanManual2009.pdf
And it supports Independents. Hooray.
There has never been a time in my life, not one, when I have wished I was in marketing.
My fur is ruffled. We cats like to contemplate our potential reading matter in an atmosphere of peace and calm.
Purrhaps it is just as well you did not make it to that meeting! Miaou!
Hello Catriona, this cat likes peace and quiet too!
Ali – love the ABA slogan and in the new blog post I’ve appropriated it for my own ends.
Silver Eel – quite liked the quotes on the W’stone’s bags. Which I’m horrified to admit. It was simple, interesting, cheap and didn’t detract from the content of the books.
And Jane – you would be rubbish in marketing; you’re far too honest!
[...] events and have good marketing ideas (agreeing with us that ‘bookaholism’ is a lousy idea for a marketing strategy is probably A Good Thing). You also need to be well-read and to be a strong fiction buyer as we [...]
[...] only in the comments section on The Bookseller’s online edition – and when I wrote about it here and here the idea was given fairly short shrift by our commenters. Since then I haven’t [...]
[...] also something we’ve been advocating since last summer’s pathetic attempt to develop bookaholism as an industry-wide marketing concept (see how we suggested using the Eat, Sleep, Read slogan [...]